Crisis help

Family digital agreements: how to build them without fighting

Why screen agreements fail and how to build one that holds up.

2 min read

Why they fail

Because they are almost always set by one side only, with no conversation, with rules that apply to the kids and not to the adults. An agreement that doesn't feel fair doesn't hold up.

What a good agreement has

  • It applies to everyone at home, not just the teen.
  • It comes with a reason that has been explained, not just a rule.
  • It was put together with their input.
  • It has clear consequences if it isn't kept, and they are enforced.

Five questions to build it

  1. 1"What seems fine to you about how screens get used right now?" Start with what's working.
  2. 2"What do you think causes the most conflict?" Name it without accusing.
  3. 3"What rules would seem fair to you?" Listen before proposing.
  4. 4"What can we both commit to changing?" Make it mutual.
  5. 5Write it down and review it in a month.
How to say it

Instead of

"In this house, I make the rules."

Try

"I want us to build something that works for both of us."

Instead of

"No phone after nine."

Try

"What time seems reasonable to you for putting the phone away?"

Instead of

"If you don't stick to it, I'm taking it away."

Try

"If the agreement isn't kept, what consequence seems fair to you?"

Instead of

"I'm taking it away, end of story."

Try

"We need a clearer and more doable way to handle this."

Myths and facts

Myth

"If I set limits, they'll just use it more behind my back."

Fact

Limits that are reasonable and talked through are respected more than ones that are imposed.

Myth

"I already tried and it didn't work."

Fact

An agreement built by the two of you has a better chance than one that's imposed.

Myth

"It's a losing battle."

Fact

It isn't. It takes consistency and flexibility.

Myth

"The only thing that works is one big, final limit."

Fact

Specific adjustments tend to work better: one focus at a time.

Where to start

Don't try to sort out the whole relationship with screens at once. Pick one focus: nighttime, meals or study time. Set one short, clear guideline for that focus, and review it after a few days.

A question to take with you

What screen agreement would you be willing to follow yourself, too?

Signs to get help right away

It's best to talk to a professional right away if:

  • Nighttime use is costing them sleep on an ongoing basis.
  • They have cut themselves off from almost all their offline relationships.
  • There is aggression or a very intense outburst when you try to limit their use.
  • They stopped going to school, or dropped activities they once kept up.
  • There are signs that they saw something that disturbed them, that an adult is contacting them inappropriately, or that someone is pressuring them, threatening them or asking them for images.
  • They are betting money online or spending without being able to stop.

If someone is threatening them or asking them for images, don't delete the messages: save screenshots and get help. The fact that they told you is what matters most. Don't punish them for it.

You don't have to wait for the problem to get bigger to ask for help.

Next resourceBack to the resources

Only the resource is shared. Never your answers or your reading.